| 1 Donovan Ricketts 27 Mikael Silvestre 12 David Horst 5 Michael Harrington 13 Jack Jewsbury 21 Diego Chará 22 Rodney Wallace 4 Will Johnson 9 Ryan Johnson 6 Darlington Nagbe 8 Diego Valeri |
| Substitution |
| 20 Adolfo Valencia 10 Frederic Piquionne 2 Ryan Miller 30 Milos Kocic 14 Ben Zemanski 11 Kalif Alhassan 35 Andrew Jean Baptiste |
| 1 Tally Hall 4 Jermaine Taylor 32 Bobby Boswell 26 Corey Ashe 8 Kofi Sarkodie 16 Adam Moffat 13 Ricardo Clark 11 Brad Davis 20 Andrew Driver 12 Will Bruin 23 Giles Barnes |
| Substitution |
| 6 Mike Chabala 7 Omar Cummings 2 Eric Brunner 25 Brian Ching 24 Tyler Deric 17 Luiz Camargo 5 Warren Creavalle |
