| 1 Donovan Ricketts 44 Pa-Modou Kah 35 Andrew Jean Baptiste 5 Michael Harrington 23 Alvas Powell 21 Diego Chará 14 Ben Zemanski 8 Diego Valeri 9 Ryan Johnson 22 Rodney Wallace 6 Darlington Nagbe |
| Substitution |
| 20 Adolfo Valencia 7 Salvatore Zizzo 2 Ryan Miller 31 Rauwshan McKenzie 30 Milos Kocic 13 Jack Jewsbury 11 Kalif Alhassan |
| 1 Raúl Fernández 24 Matt Hedges 14 George John 31 Michel 23 Kellyn Acosta 10 David Arturo Ferreira 20 Mauro Alberto Díaz 12 Erick 6 Jackson 11 Fabian Castillo 7 Blas Pérez |
| Substitution |
| 22 Stephen Keel 5 Jair Benítez 33 Kenny Cooper 18 Chris Seitz 9 Ramón Núñez 27 Je-Vaughn Watson 25 Walker Zimmerman |
