| Minute | Score | New York Red Bulls | Orlando City | |
| 3' | 0 - 1 |  Larin C. (Ramos R.) |
||
| 50' | 0 - 1 | McCarty D. |
||
| 64' | 0 - 1 |  Rivas C. (Baptista J.) |
||
| 65' | 1 - 1 | Grella M. (Kljestan S.) |
||
| 69' | 2 - 1 | Wright-Phillips B. (Grella M.) |
||
| 75' | 3 - 1 | Wright-Phillips B. (Sam L.) |
||
| 77' | 3 - 1 | Barry H. (Winter A.) |
||
| 80' | 3 - 1 | Davis S. (McCarty D.) |
||
| 83' | 3 - 1 | Rivas C. |
||
| 84' | 3 - 2 | Ouimette K. (Own goal) |
||
| 88' | 3 - 2 | Muyl A. (Sam L.) |
||
| 89' | 3 - 2 | Duvall C. (Zizzo S.) |
