| Minute | Score | Hartlepool United FC | Rotherham United | |
| 1' | 3 - 2 | Featherstone N. (Penalty) |
||
| 1' | 3 - 3 | Smith M. (Penalty) |
||
| 2' | 4 - 3 | Sterry J. (Penalty) |
||
| 2' | 4 - 4 | Ferguson S. (Penalty) |
||
| 3' | 5 - 4 | Shelton M. (Penalty) |
||
| 3' | 5 - 5 | Barlaser D. (Penalty) |
||
| 4' | 5 - 5 | Molyneux L. (Penalty missed) |
||
| 4' | 5 - 5 | Wiles B. (Penalty missed) |
||
| 5' | 6 - 5 | Bogle O. (Penalty) |
||
| 6' | 6 - 6 | MacDonald A. (Penalty) |
||
| 23' | 0 - 0 |  Wood R. |
||
| 29' | 1 - 0 | Grey J. (Ferguson D.) |
||
| 32' | 1 - 0 | Byrne N. |
||
| 34' | 1 - 0 |  Miller M. (Lindsay J.) |
||
| 40' | 1 - 0 | Edmonds-Green R. |
||
| 46' | 1 - 0 | Rathbone O. (Odoffin H.) |
||
| 46' | 1 - 0 | Ihiekwe M. (Wood R.) |
||
| 50' | 1 - 1 | Smith M. (Barlaser D.) |
||
| 55' | 2 - 1 | Molyneux L. (Grey J.) |
||
| 61' | 2 - 1 | Ogbene C. (Bola T.) |
||
| 63' | 2 - 2 | Smith M. (Ogbene C.) |
||
| 85' | 2 - 2 | Carver M. (Grey J.) |
