| Minute | Score | Columbus Crew | Orlando City | |
| 13' | 0 - 0 |  Mendez J. |
||
| 20' | 1 - 0 | Berry M. (Zelarayan L.) |
||
| 31' | 2 - 0 | Etienne D. (Zelarayan L.) |
||
| 45' | 2 - 0 | Mensah J. |
||
| 46' | 2 - 0 |  Michel B. (Nani) |
||
| 46' | 2 - 0 | Akindele T. (Mendez J.) |
||
| 52' | 2 - 1 | Dike D. (Penalty) |
||
| 57' | 2 - 1 | Smith K. |
||
| 61' | 3 - 1 | Zelarayan L. (Moreira S.) |
||
| 70' | 3 - 1 | Fraser L. (Hairston M.) |
||
| 73' | 3 - 1 | Pato (Mueller C.) |
||
| 73' | 3 - 1 | Mas E. (Smith K.) |
||
| 75' | 3 - 1 | Afful H. (Zelarayan L.) |
||
| 86' | 3 - 1 | Williams J. (Wormgoor V.) |
||
| 87' | 3 - 1 | Keita A. (Nagbe D.) |
