| Minute | Score | Columbus Crew | Cincinnati | |
| 45' | 1 - 0 | Zelarayan L. |
||
| 62' | 1 - 0 | Francis W. (Diaz L.) |
||
| 65' | 1 - 0 | Atanga I. (Valot F.) |
||
| 70' | 1 - 0 | Vazquez B. (Brenner) |
||
| 73' | 1 - 0 | Berry M. (Wright-Phillips B.) |
||
| 74' | 1 - 1 | Atanga I. (Acosta L.) |
||
| 77' | 1 - 1 | Matan A. (Fraser L.) |
||
| 77' | 1 - 1 | Keita A. (Wormgoor V.) |
||
| 81' | 2 - 1 | Berry M. |
||
| 83' | 3 - 1 | Berry M. |
||
| 89' | 3 - 1 | Medunjanin H. (Cameron G.) |
