| Minute | Score | Cincinnati | New York City Fc | |
| 1' | 0 - 1 |  Acosta L. (Penalty) |
||
| 2' | 0 - 2 | Asad Y. (Penalty) |
||
| 3' | 0 - 3 | Santos S. (Penalty) |
||
| 4' | 0 - 3 |  Bucha P. (Penalty missed) |
||
| 5' | 0 - 4 | Kelsy K. (Penalty) |
||
| 6' | 0 - 5 | Robinson M. (Penalty) |
||
| 7' | 0 - 5 | Valenzuela G. (Penalty missed) |
||
| 65' | 0 - 0 |  Bucha P. |
||
| 71' | 0 - 0 |  Santos S. (Kubo Y.) |
||
| 84' | 0 - 0 | Kelsy K. (Orellano L.) |
||
| 84' | 0 - 0 | Powell A. (Yedlin D.) |
||
| 85' | 0 - 0 | Powell A. |
||
| 89' | 0 - 0 | Valenzuela G. (Nwobodo O.) |
